The future is going to be different from the present. Let's think about how. Specifically, our expectations about what's reasonable are downstream of our past experiences, and those experiences were downstream of our options (and the options other people in our society had). As those options change, so too our experiences, and so too our expectations of what's reasonable. I once thought it was reasonable to pick up the phone and call someone when I wanted to talk to them, and to pick up my phone when it rang; things have changed, and someone thinking about what's possible could have seen the dilution of that signal into noise coming.

So let's try to see more things coming, and maybe that will give us the ability to choose what it will actually look like. I think lots of people's intuitions and expectations about "privacy" will be violated, as technology develops, and we should try to figure out a good spot to land. This line of thinking was prompted by one of Anthropic's 'red lines' that they declined to cross, which got the Department of War mad at them; the idea of "no domestic bulk surveillance." I want to investigate that in a roundabout way, first stepping back and asking…